Wednesday, September 2, 2026
The point is simply that huge disparities in wealth, property, and status make a mockery of freedom. The consolidation of wealth and power over the past forty years in the United States, mimicked more recently in many states in the Global South following neoliberal policies, has created a situation that the anarchists foresaw. Cumulative inequalities in access to political influence via sheer economic muscle, huge (statelike) oligopolies, media control, campaign contributions, the shaping of legislation (right down to designated loopholes), redistricting, access to legal knowledge, and the like have allowed elections and legislation to serve largely to amplify existing inequalities. It is hard to see any plausible way in which such self-reinforcing inequalities could be reduced through existing institutions... Democratic institutions have, to a great extent, become commodities themselves, offered up for auction to the highest bidder.
I don’t know if it is possible to fix this through existing political mechanisms. When James Scott wrote this back in 2012, things were not nearly so dysfunctional as they are now.
Trump seems to have taken up a hobby in the sphere of onomatology1. His interest is in reassigning hydronyms - the names of bodies of water. Maybe we can call his interest hydro-onomatology. Last year, in the wake of some pointless disagreement with Mexico, he issued an executive order renaming the Gulf of Mexico as “Gulf of America.” Now amidst a trade spat with Canada, he has done the same thing with Canada, styling Lake Ontario as “Lake America.” The names are as unjustified as they are unimaginative, but more importantly, the whole exercise is ridiculous. A journalist recently asked Prime Minister Mark Carney about U.S. Cabinet officials mocking Canada and its military. Carney replied simply: “It’s beneath their office.”
In four words, Carney summarized one of the most infuriating things about Trump and his Cabinet and supporters. None of them has an ounce of dignity. When Trump won the presidency the first time, we were told to respect the office if not the current occupant. The problem is the current occupant himself doesn’t respect the office, so why must we?
-
Onomatology,or onomastics is the branch of lexicology that deals with naming of things. ↩︎
